Female tutor in classroom with female student Female tutor in classroom with female student

What can England learn from international catch-up strategies?

Emily Yeomans, Director of NTP Tuition Partners, shares insights from a recent event on how other countries are responding to school closures.

Attainment gaps between pupils from disadvantaged backgrounds and their classmates exist in countries worldwide with concerns that school closures due to Covid-19 will exacerbate inequalities further. In England a recent analysis by the Education Endowment Foundation (EEF) suggested that the attainment gap is likely to be growing significantly while schools are closed for most pupils.

As countries across the world grapple with this problem, attention has turned to tutoring, with evidence suggesting its effectiveness and its implementation model meaning it can be targeted to those pupils who need it the most.

On January 12th, the EEF hosted an international event to share insights from England’s National Tutoring Programme (NTP) and to find out about similar ideas in the Netherlands and the United States. Here we consider five challenges that all catch up programmes are likely to face, what needs to be in place to successfully roll out new programmes, and how they can be integrated into a system to form a sustained rather than transient response.

How are other countries responding to the challenge of Covid learning loss?

The EEF invited a team from Brown University, led by Professor Susanna Loeb and Professor Matt Kraft, as well as a team from VU University, Amsterdam led by Melanie Ehren, Professor of Educational Governance.

Kraft and his colleague Grace Falken recently published a working paper that outlines a thought experiment on how tutoring could be scaled nationally. The vision in the paper is for tutoring to become a core feature of the US education system, rather than just being a short-term response to Covid. Loeb leads the National Student Support Accelerator, providing tools for organisations that want to deliver tutoring, and setting up six tutoring test sites to test different models of tutoring and understand barriers to implementation and drivers of success.

Meanwhile in the Netherlands, the Dutch government has funded a two-year programme of additional support for students in primary, secondary and vocational schools. Schools can provide support in different ways, but with the intention that support is provided in addition to the school day and that a large proportion of the funding will be spent on tutoring. The team from VU University Amsterdam is working to evaluate the programme and learn more about which of the approaches chosen by schools are most successful.

It will be interesting to monitor developments in these initiatives over this year, with England’s effort likely to be able to learn from the roll out of these programmes. However, there are already a number of lessons to draw from these global efforts.

Any response to school closures needs to ensure that current inequalities do not result in unequal access to any catch up offers.

Challenge 1: Ensuring that efforts do not inadvertently widen attainment gaps

Any response to school closures needs to ensure that current inequalities do not result in unequal access to any catch up offers.

Access to tutoring is often limited to the schools and parents that can most afford it. It is estimated that around 80% of disadvantaged pupils currently do not have access to quality tuition. Before tutoring can be part of the solution, we therefore need to ensure that supply is available across the country – growing the supply of high-quality tutoring and directing it to those pupils who need it the most.

A current success of the NTP is that we are seeing schools from Northumberland to Cornwall accessing tutoring, utilising tutors on the ground for face-to-face provision along with online tutoring to provide more tutors to geographically hard to reach areas. Growing local supply will need to remain as a key priority in England, providing schools and pupils across the country with a legacy of trained tutors that are grounded within local communities.

Challenge 2: Ensuring fidelity to the things that matter

When implementing catch up strategies we need to be clear about both the non-negotiables required for positive impacts, and the flexibilities that require the input of teacher expertise.

Tutoring will only have a positive impact if it is high-quality and the evidence base informs us about the features required to make it a success. From the evidence we know the critical features: training for tutors; close collaboration with schools and alignment to the curriculum; sessions delivered over a sustained period with the same tutor; and delivery at school (to ensure coordination with teachers and regular attendance by pupils). These elements were all considered when Tuition Partners were initially selected and will be monitored throughout the programme.

Starting smaller, implementing processes to monitor quality, and making improvements prior to further scaling is a process that is likely to support the success of any catch-up programme.

Challenge 3: Maintaining quality at scale

Reaching all the pupils that require catch up will always be challenging – enough supply of any programme or approach needs to be secured, while also ensuring quality as programmes grow.

The NTP will reach up to 250,000 pupils over the 20/21 academic year, with this number representing a large scale-up of high-quality tutoring targeted at disadvantaged pupils. However, more children will need to be reached in the future and with any increase to scale comes challenges around quality.

Starting smaller, implementing processes to monitor quality, and making improvements prior to further scaling is a process that is likely to support the success of any catch-up programme.

Challenge 4: Continuing to learn and improve throughout delivery

Ideas should never remain static and we can always learn how to improve delivery. Any catch-up programme should not try to reinvent the wheel and should be informed from the start by the existing evidence base. However, large-scale programmes are also great opportunities to update what we know.

The first year of the NTP will be independently evaluated by a consortium of NFER, Kantar and the University of Westminster. The evaluation aims to quantify the overall impact of the Tuition Partners pillar on pupil attainment and will look at how this varies by different types of tutoring, pupil, and school characteristics. The evaluation will also explore the experiences of schools, tutors, and pupils in order to improve the delivery of similar programmes in the future.

The NTP will provide important additional support for pupils this academic year, however it is not a standalone solution. Catch-up approaches therefore need to form a longer-term part of the system, alongside other investments in education to ensure quality first teaching for all pupils.

Challenge 5: Integrating new ideas into an existing system

New policies can often be short-term in nature and programmes may be buffeted by external events. When addressing the impacts of school closures it is important that we recognise this is a challenge that will be around for some time to come and that we need to plan for a sustained and integrated response that complements, rather than supplants, any existing supports.

The NTP will provide important additional support for pupils this academic year, however it is not a standalone solution. Catch-up approaches therefore need to form a longer-term part of the system, alongside other investments in education to ensure quality first teaching for all pupils.

There is no quick fix for the negative effects of school closures and this is something the education sector will need to work on for years to come. Every country in the world is facing the same challenges and learning from global efforts is critical if we are to ensure that the lives of children will not be blighted in the long-term. In this time of crisis there is the real opportunity to make changes to the education system for the long-term, challenging inequalities that existed before the pandemic, but which must not continue to persist after it ends.

Why should schools utilise the National Tutoring Programme? Blog
Andy Mellor 15 November, 2021

Why should schools utilise the National Tutoring Programme?

Discover Why should schools utilise the National Tutoring Programme?
Expert training for tutors available to schools through School-Led Tutoring as part of the National Tutoring Programme Press Releases
National Tutoring Programme 8 November, 2021

Expert training for tutors available to schools through School-Led Tutoring as part of the National Tutoring Programme

Discover Expert training for tutors available to schools through School-Led Tutoring as part of the National Tutoring Programme
Why becoming an Academic Mentor is the perfect first job for graduates Blog
National Tutoring Programme 1 November, 2021

Why becoming an Academic Mentor is the perfect first job for graduates

Discover Why becoming an Academic Mentor is the perfect first job for graduates
Becoming an Academic Mentor is a chance to start your teaching career Blog
National Tutoring Programme 22 October, 2021

Becoming an Academic Mentor is a chance to start your teaching career

Discover Becoming an Academic Mentor is a chance to start your teaching career
Building confidence in the classroom Blog
National Tutoring Programme 18 October, 2021

Building confidence in the classroom

Discover Building confidence in the classroom
Building on the successes of 2020/21 – NTP Tuition Partner Q&A
National Tutoring Programme 11 October, 2021

Building on the successes of 2020/21 – NTP Tuition Partner Q&A

Discover Building on the successes of 2020/21 – NTP Tuition Partner Q&A
Will your school be part of the catch-up learning revolution? Blog
National Tutoring Programme 6 October, 2021

Will your school be part of the catch-up learning revolution?

Discover Will your school be part of the catch-up learning revolution?
Becoming an Academic Mentor is a great taster to teaching. Blog
Jody Harrison 28 September, 2021

Becoming an Academic Mentor is a great taster to teaching.

Discover Becoming an Academic Mentor is a great taster to teaching.
Make a difference to a pupil by positively shaping their education and their future success Blog
National Tutoring Programme 23 September, 2021

Make a difference to a pupil by positively shaping their education and their future success

Discover Make a difference to a pupil by positively shaping their education and their future success
Five reasons why you should consider becoming an Academic Mentor Blog
National Tutoring Programme 10 September, 2021

Five reasons why you should consider becoming an Academic Mentor

Discover Five reasons why you should consider becoming an Academic Mentor
Get ready for a career in education by playing a key role as an Academic Mentor Blog
Martin Hopkins 3 September, 2021

Get ready for a career in education by playing a key role as an Academic Mentor

Discover Get ready for a career in education by playing a key role as an Academic Mentor
Tutoring revolution builds as students return to class Press Releases
National Tutoring Programme 2 September, 2021

Tutoring revolution builds as students return to class

Discover Tutoring revolution builds as students return to class
Continuing our journey on the road to education recovery – the NTP enters year two Blog
Karen Guthrie 25 August, 2021

Continuing our journey on the road to education recovery – the NTP enters year two

Discover Continuing our journey on the road to education recovery – the NTP enters year two
Passing the baton: NTP Year 1 roundup News
Emily Yeomans 20 August, 2021

Passing the baton: NTP Year 1 roundup

Discover Passing the baton: NTP Year 1 roundup
Staindrop Academy, Darlington School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 14 July, 2021

Staindrop Academy, Darlington

Discover Staindrop Academy, Darlington
Benton Park Primary School, Newcastle upon Tyne School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 9 July, 2021

Benton Park Primary School, Newcastle upon Tyne

Discover Benton Park Primary School, Newcastle upon Tyne
Addressing learning gaps now and building resilient systems for tomorrow Blog
Lou Aisenberg 6 July, 2021

Addressing learning gaps now and building resilient systems for tomorrow

Discover Addressing learning gaps now and building resilient systems for tomorrow
Small Heath Leadership Academy, Birmingham School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 14 June, 2021

Small Heath Leadership Academy, Birmingham

Discover Small Heath Leadership Academy, Birmingham
St Giles Church of England Primary School, Walsall School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 8 June, 2021

St Giles Church of England Primary School, Walsall

Discover St Giles Church of England Primary School, Walsall
Providing a fresh voice: Rebecca Cracknell, English tutor with Connex Education Partnership School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 3 June, 2021

Providing a fresh voice: Rebecca Cracknell, English tutor with Connex Education Partnership

Discover Providing a fresh voice: Rebecca Cracknell, English tutor with Connex Education Partnership
NTP delivery partner for 2021/22 announced by Department for Education News
National Tutoring Programme 2 June, 2021

NTP delivery partner for 2021/22 announced by Department for Education

Discover NTP delivery partner for 2021/22 announced by Department for Education
Wood Green Academy, Wednesbury School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 27 May, 2021

Wood Green Academy, Wednesbury

Discover Wood Green Academy, Wednesbury
University of Birmingham School School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 27 May, 2021

University of Birmingham School

Discover University of Birmingham School
Bob Slavin – A Tribute Blog
Robbie Coleman 5 May, 2021

Bob Slavin – A Tribute

Discover Bob Slavin – A Tribute
Bacon’s College, Southwark School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 29 April, 2021

Bacon’s College, Southwark

Discover Bacon’s College, Southwark
University Technical College Norfolk, Norwich School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 26 April, 2021

University Technical College Norfolk, Norwich

Discover University Technical College Norfolk, Norwich
Rokeby Park Primary School, Hull School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 20 April, 2021

Rokeby Park Primary School, Hull

Discover Rokeby Park Primary School, Hull
St Petroc’s Church of England Primary School, Bodmin School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 7 April, 2021

St Petroc’s Church of England Primary School, Bodmin

Discover St Petroc’s Church of England Primary School, Bodmin
Spring term roundup for the National Tutoring Programme Blog
Maariyah Dawood 1 April, 2021

Spring term roundup for the National Tutoring Programme

Discover Spring term roundup for the National Tutoring Programme
Wigmore Primary School, Luton School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 30 March, 2021

Wigmore Primary School, Luton

Discover Wigmore Primary School, Luton
Blenheim Primary School, Orpington School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 25 March, 2021

Blenheim Primary School, Orpington

Discover Blenheim Primary School, Orpington
Learning from feedback: what schools think about the NTP Blog
Amy Ellis-Thompson 23 March, 2021

Learning from feedback: what schools think about the NTP

Discover Learning from feedback: what schools think about the NTP
Uxbridge High School, Hillingdon School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 22 March, 2021

Uxbridge High School, Hillingdon

Discover Uxbridge High School, Hillingdon
Using overseas tutors to deliver NTP tuition Blog
National Tutoring Programme 19 March, 2021

Using overseas tutors to deliver NTP tuition

Discover Using overseas tutors to deliver NTP tuition
St John and James Church of England Primary School, Enfield School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 18 March, 2021

St John and James Church of England Primary School, Enfield

Discover St John and James Church of England Primary School, Enfield
Woodfall Primary and Nursery School, Neston School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 15 March, 2021

Woodfall Primary and Nursery School, Neston

Discover Woodfall Primary and Nursery School, Neston
Green Fold Specialist Primary School, Bolton School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 12 March, 2021

Green Fold Specialist Primary School, Bolton

Discover Green Fold Specialist Primary School, Bolton
Stoke Damerel Primary Academy, Plymouth School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 8 March, 2021

Stoke Damerel Primary Academy, Plymouth

Discover Stoke Damerel Primary Academy, Plymouth
Making tutoring count: cost, quality and value for money Blog
Robbie Coleman 26 February, 2021

Making tutoring count: cost, quality and value for money

Discover Making tutoring count: cost, quality and value for money
The Bemrose School, Derby School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 25 February, 2021

The Bemrose School, Derby

Discover The Bemrose School, Derby
The Minster Junior School, Croydon School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 23 February, 2021

The Minster Junior School, Croydon

Discover The Minster Junior School, Croydon
NTP announces additional funding and more online places available through Tuition Partners News
National Tutoring Programme 23 February, 2021

NTP announces additional funding and more online places available through Tuition Partners

Discover NTP announces additional funding and more online places available through Tuition Partners
National Tutoring Programme supporting schools to re-open on 8th March News
National Tutoring Programme 23 February, 2021

National Tutoring Programme supporting schools to re-open on 8th March

Discover National Tutoring Programme supporting schools to re-open on 8th March
Duke’s Secondary School, Ashington School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 16 February, 2021

Duke’s Secondary School, Ashington

Discover Duke’s Secondary School, Ashington
5 key findings from the National Online Tutoring Pilot Blog
Kathryn Davies 12 February, 2021

5 key findings from the National Online Tutoring Pilot

Discover 5 key findings from the National Online Tutoring Pilot
Morland Church of England Primary School, Ipswich School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 10 February, 2021

Morland Church of England Primary School, Ipswich

Discover Morland Church of England Primary School, Ipswich
Changing with the times: Action Tutoring and home-based tuition Blog
National Tutoring Programme 8 February, 2021

Changing with the times: Action Tutoring and home-based tuition

Discover Changing with the times: Action Tutoring and home-based tuition
Severn View Primary Academy, Stroud School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 8 February, 2021

Severn View Primary Academy, Stroud

Discover Severn View Primary Academy, Stroud
4 ways to make the most of online tuition from home Blog
Amy Ellis-Thompson 4 February, 2021

4 ways to make the most of online tuition from home

Discover 4 ways to make the most of online tuition from home
St John the Baptist Catholic Primary School, Andover School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 2 February, 2021

St John the Baptist Catholic Primary School, Andover

Discover St John the Baptist Catholic Primary School, Andover
Churchill Community College, Wallsend School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 28 January, 2021

Churchill Community College, Wallsend

Discover Churchill Community College, Wallsend
Kingswood Academy, Hull School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 25 January, 2021

Kingswood Academy, Hull

Discover Kingswood Academy, Hull
Upton-by-Chester High School, Chester School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 22 January, 2021

Upton-by-Chester High School, Chester

Discover Upton-by-Chester High School, Chester
Brompton Westbrook Primary School, Gillingham School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 13 January, 2021

Brompton Westbrook Primary School, Gillingham

Discover Brompton Westbrook Primary School, Gillingham
Flourishing in difficult circumstances: The Access Project and online tuition Blog
National Tutoring Programme 11 January, 2021

Flourishing in difficult circumstances: The Access Project and online tuition

Discover Flourishing in difficult circumstances: The Access Project and online tuition
What does the new lockdown mean for the National Tutoring Programme? Blog
Rhian Allman 7 January, 2021

What does the new lockdown mean for the National Tutoring Programme?

Discover What does the new lockdown mean for the National Tutoring Programme?
NTP update on school contingency plans from January 2021 News
National Tutoring Programme 4 January, 2021

NTP update on school contingency plans from January 2021

Discover NTP update on school contingency plans from January 2021
National Tutoring Programme Tuition Partners reach 62,000 pupils in first term News
National Tutoring Programme 21 December, 2020

National Tutoring Programme Tuition Partners reach 62,000 pupils in first term

Discover National Tutoring Programme Tuition Partners reach 62,000 pupils in first term
‘Tuition provides a safe environment to address gaps in learning’ – Mary Barnard, English tutor at Action Tutoring School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 18 December, 2020

‘Tuition provides a safe environment to address gaps in learning’ – Mary Barnard, English tutor at Action Tutoring

Discover ‘Tuition provides a safe environment to address gaps in learning’ – Mary Barnard, English tutor at Action Tutoring
Happy Christmas from the National Tutoring Programme! Blog
Robbie Coleman 18 December, 2020

Happy Christmas from the National Tutoring Programme!

Discover Happy Christmas from the National Tutoring Programme!
Learning lessons from new global evidence on tutoring Blog
Amy Ellis-Thompson 14 December, 2020

Learning lessons from new global evidence on tutoring

Discover Learning lessons from new global evidence on tutoring
St Mary’s Church of England Primary School, Bridport School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 8 December, 2020

St Mary’s Church of England Primary School, Bridport

Discover St Mary’s Church of England Primary School, Bridport
Thorntree Academy, Middlesbrough School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 8 December, 2020

Thorntree Academy, Middlesbrough

Discover Thorntree Academy, Middlesbrough
South Norwood Primary School – The Pioneer Academy School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 8 December, 2020

South Norwood Primary School – The Pioneer Academy

Discover South Norwood Primary School – The Pioneer Academy
The Duchess’s Community High School, Alnwick School Stories
National Tutoring Programme 8 December, 2020

The Duchess’s Community High School, Alnwick

Discover The Duchess’s Community High School, Alnwick
Quality, experience and impact: selecting our NTP Tuition Partners Blog
Liberty King 1 December, 2020

Quality, experience and impact: selecting our NTP Tuition Partners

Discover Quality, experience and impact: selecting our NTP Tuition Partners
10 common questions about the National Tutoring Programme Blog
Maariyah Dawood 19 November, 2020

10 common questions about the National Tutoring Programme

Discover 10 common questions about the National Tutoring Programme
The National Foundation for Educational Research (NFER) to lead evaluation of NTP Tuition Partners Press Releases
National Tutoring Programme 11 November, 2020

The National Foundation for Educational Research (NFER) to lead evaluation of NTP Tuition Partners

Discover The National Foundation for Educational Research (NFER) to lead evaluation of NTP Tuition Partners
National Tutoring Programme launches in schools Press Releases
National Tutoring Programme 2 November, 2020

National Tutoring Programme launches in schools

Discover National Tutoring Programme launches in schools
How to access tutoring for your pupils through NTP Tuition Partners Blog
Emily Yeomans 30 October, 2020

How to access tutoring for your pupils through NTP Tuition Partners

Discover How to access tutoring for your pupils through NTP Tuition Partners
Online tutoring helps disadvantaged pupils during lockdown, study finds Press Releases
National Tutoring Programme 21 October, 2020

Online tutoring helps disadvantaged pupils during lockdown, study finds

Discover Online tutoring helps disadvantaged pupils during lockdown, study finds
Busting two common myths about tutoring Blog
Robbie Coleman 16 October, 2020

Busting two common myths about tutoring

Discover Busting two common myths about tutoring
The NTP has a vital role to play in mitigating the effects of Covid-19 school closures Blog
Robbie Coleman 1 October, 2020

The NTP has a vital role to play in mitigating the effects of Covid-19 school closures

Discover The NTP has a vital role to play in mitigating the effects of Covid-19 school closures
NTP Tuition Partners: Best practice for tutoring organisations News
National Tutoring Programme 3 September, 2020

NTP Tuition Partners: Best practice for tutoring organisations

Discover NTP Tuition Partners: Best practice for tutoring organisations
Making sure tutoring makes a difference in your school News
National Tutoring Programme 1 September, 2020

Making sure tutoring makes a difference in your school

Discover Making sure tutoring makes a difference in your school
Harnessing expertise and energy to provide additional support to disadvantaged pupils Blog
Emily Yeomans 1 September, 2020

Harnessing expertise and energy to provide additional support to disadvantaged pupils

Discover Harnessing expertise and energy to provide additional support to disadvantaged pupils
NTP: reshaping access to tutoring Blog
Jed Cinnamon 26 August, 2020

NTP: reshaping access to tutoring

Discover NTP: reshaping access to tutoring
Looking ahead to the new school year Blog
Becky Francis 24 August, 2020

Looking ahead to the new school year

Discover Looking ahead to the new school year
Blog: National Tutoring Programme Blog
Robbie Coleman 14 August, 2020

Blog: National Tutoring Programme

Discover Blog: National Tutoring Programme
Academic Mentors Programme: helping your pupils after COVID-19 Blog
Russell Hobby 20 July, 2020

Academic Mentors Programme: helping your pupils after COVID-19

Discover Academic Mentors Programme: helping your pupils after COVID-19
The National Tutoring Programme is a huge opportunity to support schools and pupils Blog
Becky Francis 25 June, 2020

The National Tutoring Programme is a huge opportunity to support schools and pupils

Discover The National Tutoring Programme is a huge opportunity to support schools and pupils
The need to widen access to tutoring Blog
James Turner 22 June, 2020

The need to widen access to tutoring

Discover The need to widen access to tutoring
National Tutoring Programme launched to support pupils in schools across in England Press Releases
National Tutoring Programme 18 June, 2020

National Tutoring Programme launched to support pupils in schools across in England

Discover National Tutoring Programme launched to support pupils in schools across in England